Winter battery arbitrage math
10kWh battery, 85% round-trip efficiency, winter cycle (Nov-Feb):
Charge off-peak (midnight-6am, 10am-2pm) at 13.1¢/kWh. Discharge 5-10pm (heating peak) at 52.4¢/kWh. Gross spread: 39.3¢/kWh. After 15% loss: 33.4¢/kWh net per cycle. 10 kWh × $0.334 = $3.34/day net minimum. On heating-stress days (cold snaps), peak prices spike to 70-90¢/kWh: $5-12/day.
Over 4 months (Nov-Feb): $400-1,500 from battery alone. A $10k-15k system amortizes in 6-9 years.
Add a Kalshi hedge: Bet on heating demand / high temps / supply stress. Free-roll your physical arbitrage with financial upside.
$5-12/day
Winter battery ROI (cold days)
39.3¢
Off-peak to peak spread
4 months
Heating season window (Nov-Feb)
Summer vs winter battery ROI (side by side)
| Metric | Summer (Jun-Sep) | Winter (Nov-Feb) | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Off-peak rate | 13.1¢/kWh | 13.1¢/kWh | Same |
| Peak rate | 80.2¢ (4-9pm AC) | 52.4¢ (5-10pm heat) | -35% per kWh |
| Gross spread | 67.1¢/kWh | 39.3¢/kWh | -41% spread |
| Net (85% efficiency) | 57¢/kWh | 33.4¢/kWh | -41% |
| 10kWh battery/day | $2-4 | $3-12 | +50-200% |
| Why higher in winter? | Peak is volatile (AC demand spikes) | Peak is CONSISTENT (heating fires every day) | Predictability matters |
| Kalshi hedge | Risky (AC = weather dependent) | Strong signal (heating = predictable load) | Carves work better |
Example: Summer peak (80.2¢) only happens 4-9pm on AC days. Winter peak (52.4¢) happens 5-10pm every day, even on warm days, because heating load is on the dispatch stack. Winter is LESS spikey but MORE consistent = better for battery scheduling + betting hedges.
The winter battery strategy
Goal: Charge battery cheaply, discharge expensively, hedge the signal with Kalshi.
- Charge windows: Midnight-6am (super off-peak, 13.1¢) or 10am-2pm (off-peak, 13.1¢). Use whichever fits your schedule. Prefer midnight if you have solar + storage, because daytime solar charges free.
- Discharge window: 5-10pm. Heating load is on. Grid operators call for conservation. Prices rise. Discharge fully (unless you have a second battery or solar incoming).
- Cold snap response: When NWS issues heat warnings or when temps dip below 50°F, heating dispatch tightens and prices can spike. Peak can hit 70-90¢/kWh on those days. On those days, don't use battery for anything else—save it for peak discharge.
- Kalshi position: Bet on heating demand rungs or temperature lows when you have battery charged. Hedge 50-100% of your battery revenue on heating carves.
ROI calculation: real example
Setup: 10kWh battery, EV-TOU-5 plan, Solana Beach location, 4-month winter window (Nov 1 - Feb 28, 120 days).
Conservative case (avg 52.4¢ peak, 13.1¢ off-peak):
10 kWh × 39.3¢ = $3.93/day gross · 85% efficiency = $3.34/day net
$3.34 × 120 days = $400.80 winter earnings
Normal case (avg peak 62¢, cold snaps included):
10 kWh × 48.9¢ = $4.89/day gross · 85% efficiency = $4.15/day net
$4.15 × 120 days = $498 winter earnings
Stress case (peak 70¢ avg, cold snaps 80¢+):
10 kWh × 56.9¢ = $5.69/day gross · 85% efficiency = $4.84/day net
$4.84 × 120 days = $580.80 winter earnings
Add Kalshi: If you hedge half your battery revenue with heating demand carves at 2:1 payout, you could see +$200-400 additional upside on a stress winter. That's $600-980 total winter revenue from a $10k-15k investment = 4-10% annual return just on the winter window.
The Kalshi carve strategy
Prediction markets on energy (when available Nov-Dec 2026) let you hedge your physical arbitrage:
- Position 1: Long heating demand. If you're discharging battery during 5-10pm and making money on high prices, bet on high heating demand or cold temperatures. This is a free-roll: physical arbitrage profit + betting profit if cold days arrive.
- Position 2: Hedge supply stress. Bet on grid stress days (CAISO alerts). On those days, your battery discharge is worth even more, AND your Kalshi position pays out.
- Carve sizing: Start small: $50-100 per bet. A $100 bet on "heating demand high" that resolves YES pays out 2:1 (example) = $200. Pair that with a $600 battery revenue day and you're at $800 total.
When battery arbitrage breaks
Scenarios where winter battery ROI drops:
- Warm winter: If Nov-Feb temps stay above 65°F, heating load is light. Peak prices don't spike. ROI dips to $2-4/day (summer-like).
- Rate plan change: If you move to a different TOU plan (e.g., TOU-DR1), peak is only 22.7¢ vs 52.4¢. ROI collapses to $0.5-1.50/day.
- Solar output remains low: Winter solar is only 40-50% of summer. If battery is your only charging source (no solar), you're charging at retail rates (52.4¢ peak, not 13.1¢ off-peak). ROI becomes negative.
- Battery degradation: After 10 years, round-trip efficiency drops to 75-80% (vs 85% new). ROI falls 10-15%.
Your next steps
Text PJ to calculate your specific winter battery ROI: