What is energy arbitrage?
Energy arbitrage is buying cheap and selling dear. On SDG&E time-of-use rates:
- Super off-peak (midnight–6am, 10am–2pm): 13.1¢ per kWh on EV-TOU-5. Your buy window.
- On-peak (4pm–9pm): 80.2¢ per kWh on EV-TOU-5. Your sell window.
- Spread: 67.1¢ per kWh gross. Subtract battery losses (~15% round-trip) and that's your net margin.
Without a battery, you arbitrage your time: charge the EV at 1am instead of 6pm. With a battery, you arbitrage your dollars: charge at cheap hours, discharge at peak, pocket the spread daily.
Where the spreads live
The main stage. Buy super off-peak (13.1¢), sell at peak (80.2¢). 67¢ spread, every single day on EV-TOU-5.
Noon: 5.5¢. 6pm: 19.2¢. Use solar yourself at noon; battery's job is to save it for 6–9pm when SDG&E pays 3.5x more.
10kWh battery charged at 13.1¢, discharged at 80.2¢, with 85% round-trip efficiency = $2.40–3.60/day. $876–1,314/year gross (before equipment amortization).
Hedge your physical arbitrage with financial positions. Short high temps (push prices down). Long supply stress (push prices up). Free-roll your grid signal into betting.
Wholesale prices fluctuate 4.4¢–13.4¢/kWh. That's the 5-minute market under your bill. Futures on CAISO exist but require a broker and capital.
Different plans have different spreads. EV-TOU-5 is widest (67¢). TOU-DR1 is narrower (22.7¢). Choose the spread that fits your hardware.
Battery math: when it makes sense
A battery system (10kWh + inverter + install, ~$10k–15k) earns $2.40–3.60/day gross. That's 6–13 year amortization at $0 financing, before maintenance. ROI flips to positive only if:
- You're on a time-of-use plan (EV-TOU-5, TOU-DR1, etc.) where the spread is real.
- Your home can discharge 6–10kWh during peak (4–9pm) most days.
- You have solar (otherwise you're just cycling grid power, and that cycle costs the spread three times: buy cheap, store loss, sell peak).
- Your installler is still in business. Dead systems: $330–416/month in stranded costs.
Wrong fit: flat-rate utilities, homes that are empty at peak, NEM 2 (export caps), or you're betting on battery prices dropping 50% in 5 years (possible, but uncertain).
Kalshi carves: hedging the arbitrage
Prediction markets on energy let you hedge your physical arbitrage. You control three risks:
- Temperature risk: hotter days = higher peak prices. If you're short (selling solar), bet on cool temps to protect yourself.
- Supply risk: brownouts push prices up. If you're long (storing energy to sell), bet on stress days to double down.
- Time risk: rates change monthly. Track CAISO futures and FERC filings to know if the spread is widening or tightening.
Kalshi's energy carves (if available) let you place $10–$100 bets that resolve based on CAISO prices or NWS heat alerts. A $100 bet on "high temps this week" combined with your battery discharge earns you profit from both the physical margin and the financial hedge. That's a free-roll on grid signal.
The people who do this
North County solar and battery experts who understand the math and help you run it:
Solar installation & NEM 3
Sizes systems, routes export pricing, handles SDG&E interconnect. Can tell you whether your roof catches noon sun or afternoon sun (that affects the export strategy).
Battery integration
Pairs battery size to your usage pattern and TOU plan. NEM 3 batteries need software tuning; mistuned batteries don't arbitrage—they just store.
EV charging optimization
Schedules charging to off-peak hours, integrates with solar + battery timing. A Level 2 charger on the right TOU plan saves $3–5 per charge vs. peak.
The live board and what it tells you
SideGuy rebuilds the board every 6 hours with:
- SDG&E peak rate right now. Tells you if it's a good hour to charge or discharge.
- Solar export value right now. Tells you if your rooftop is earning you money.
- Battery ROI for today. Tells you if the spread is wide enough to cycle your battery or wait.
- Kalshi depth (when available). Tells you odds and liquidity on related energy carves.
Winter energy season (Nov-Feb): peak arbitrage window
Heating load changes everything. Winter peak shifts 5-10pm (heating + EV charging both peak). Battery ROI 2-3x higher than summer. Three plays:
Winter solar strategy
Solar output drops 40-50% but battery ROI INCREASES. Shorter days mean less generation, but heating load is predictable 5-10pm. Store solar at noon, discharge at 6pm = $5-12/day battery ROI.
Winter battery arbitrage
Off-peak 13.1¢, winter peak 52.4¢. That's 39.3¢ spread. A 10kWh battery nets $4-10/day net over 4 months = $480-1,200. Plus Kalshi hedging = free-roll on heating demand signal.
EV charging optimization
Winter peak drives EV charging costs up 3x. Shift charging midnight-6am = 40-60% savings per charge. Fleet of 8 vehicles = $45k/year savings with smart scheduling.
Questions
What is energy arbitrage?
Buying electricity when it's cheap (midnight-6am, 10am-2pm) and using it when it's expensive (4-9pm). With a battery, you charge at cheap hours and discharge during peak, pocketing the spread. On SDG&E EV-TOU-5, the spread is 67¢ per kWh — that's the profit potential.
How much can I make with a battery?
A 10kWh battery charged at 13.1¢ and discharged at 80.2¢ (gross spread 67.1¢) nets roughly $2.40–3.60/day after efficiency losses. Over a year: $876–1,314. Battery costs $10k–15k installed, so ROI depends heavily on your usage pattern, time-of-use plan, and NEM 3 export prices.
What role do Kalshi carves play?
Kalshi prediction markets on energy let you hedge your arbitrage positions. If you're short energy (selling solar), you can bet on low prices to protect downside. If you're long (charging on cheap hours), you can bet on high peak prices. Carves integrate grid signal + betting together.
Is solar export worth it?
Yes, but only if you're on NEM 3. SDG&E's export pricing (5.5¢ noon, 19.2¢ at 6pm) means a kilowatt of solar can generate $5.50–19.20 per day in bill credits. A 6kW system generates 18–25 kWh/day on good days, so annual export value is $4,000–15,000 depending on season and plan.
What if I don't have a battery?
You still arbitrage with time: charge your EV at 1am ($13.1¢) instead of 6pm ($80.2¢) and save $0.67 per kWh. Use appliances during super off-peak hours. Pre-cool your house before 4pm. On EV-TOU-5, even without storage, you can shave $30–60/month from peak hours by time-shifting.
How do I know which rate plan to pick?
EV-TOU-5 has the widest spread (67¢) but higher on-peak rates. TOU-DR1 has a narrower spread (22.7¢) but lower overall rates. Pick based on your hardware: EV-TOU-5 if you have a battery or can shift charging; TOU-DR1 if you're time-shifting only. Compare plans here.
Ready to run your own energy math?
Text PJ or use the SideGuy Hour
Text your current bill, rate plan, and usage pattern. PJ runs the arbitrage math for your home and tells you whether a battery, solar, or EV charging timing makes financial sense. More complex? Book the SideGuy Hour ($150) for hands-on help picking a rate plan, sizing a system, or reviewing a proposal.
Know someone who needs this?
Something changed here? Text PJ and we'll update this page.
More free local tools: the North County toolkit.