Quick strategy: shift charging 8 hours
Don't charge 5-10pm in winter. That's when heating load peaks and grid prices spike to 52.4¢/kWh. Charge midnight-6am at 13.1¢/kWh instead.
70 kWh charge savings:
- Peak time (6pm): 70 kWh × 52.4¢ = $36.68
- Off-peak (1am): 70 kWh × 13.1¢ = $9.17
- Savings per charge: $27.51
Over winter (4 months, 3 charges/week): $1,100-1,650 savings per vehicle. Fleet of 10: $11k-16.5k for winter alone.
39.3¢
Off-peak to peak spread
$27.51
Per 70kWh charge savings
30-40%
Fleet cost increase at peak
Winter peak load: why EV and heating collide
Winter evening peak (5-10pm) is when the grid is running at maximum because of two overlapping loads:
- Heating load: Tens of thousands of San Diego homes turn on heating (or run heat pumps) starting at sunset. CAISO shows heating load ramping from 3pm onward.
- EV charging demand: Commuters come home from 5-7pm and plug in. A single Tesla Supercharger draws 150-250 kW. 100 chargers simultaneously = 15-25 MW of demand hitting the grid in one hour.
- Industrial/commercial: Facilities run their heaviest loads 5-9pm (HVAC, lighting, production). All three loads (heating, EV, industrial) peak at the same hour.
Result: CAISO grid operators raise prices to 52.4¢/kWh (winter peak) to tell everyone to "delay your load." The margin between off-peak (13.1¢) and peak (52.4¢) exists specifically to incentivize shifting. It's the grid's way of saying "charge at night, not now."
Individual EV charging math
Personal vehicle, 70 kWh battery (typical Tesla Model 3), EV-TOU-5 plan:
| Charging time | Rate | 70 kWh cost | Per mile (250 mi range) | vs midnight |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Midnight (super off-peak) | 13.1¢/kWh | $9.17 | $0.037/mi | baseline |
| 2am (super off-peak) | 13.1¢/kWh | $9.17 | $0.037/mi | same |
| 10am (off-peak) | 13.1¢/kWh | $9.17 | $0.037/mi | same |
| 2pm (transition) | 13.1¢/kWh | $9.17 | $0.037/mi | same |
| 4pm (ramp-up) | 49.6¢/kWh | $34.72 | $0.139/mi | +$25.55 (278%) |
| 6pm (peak) | 52.4¢/kWh | $36.68 | $0.147/mi | +$27.51 (300%) |
| 8pm (peak) | 49.6¢/kWh | $34.72 | $0.139/mi | +$25.55 (278%) |
SDG&E EV-TOU-5 rates, winter, Aug 1, 2026 effective. Charging at peak (6pm) is 3x more expensive than charging at midnight. That's not a pricing glitch—it's the grid's signal: shift your load.
Fleet EV charging: contractor case
Scenario: Electrical contractor with 8 service vehicles (all Tesla), 10-12 hour days, home base in Solana Beach.
Current practice (peak charging): Vehicles charge at shop 4-8pm after returning from jobs. 8 vehicles × 70 kWh avg = 560 kWh/day at 52.4¢ = $293/day · 4 days/week = $1,172/week charging cost.
Optimized (midnight-6am charging): Vehicles charge overnight at 13.1¢/kWh. 560 kWh/day × 13.1¢ = $73.36/day · 4 days/week = $293/week charging cost.
Savings: $879/week, $45,708/year for 8 vehicles.
How? Smart charger with automated scheduling. Install a 32A home charger with WiFi control (Wallbox, Tesla Wall Connector, etc). Schedule charging to start at midnight, stop at 6am. Vehicles are fully charged by morning dispatch. No charging during peak. Works even if vehicles return at 4pm—just delay the charge start to midnight.
Home charger scheduling: setup
What you need:
- Smart charger: Tesla Wall Connector (WiFi), Wallbox Pulsar Plus (WiFi + scheduling), or Eaton iqSTATION. Cost: $500-1,000 installed.
- TOU rate plan: Must be on EV-TOU-5 (residential) or TOU-DR1 (if small business). Call SDG&E to switch if you're still on flat-rate.
- Scheduler app: Most smart chargers have a mobile app that lets you set "charge only between midnight and 6am" or "charge only at off-peak times."
How to set it up:
- Plug in vehicle at any time (even 4pm).
- Charger waits until midnight to start drawing power.
- Charges at full speed (6-11 kW depending on charger) from midnight-6am.
- Stops at 6am or when battery reaches 80-90% (you set the threshold).
- Vehicle is fully charged by morning. No charging during peak.
Winter TOU rates: Off-peak is midnight-6am, 10am-2pm. Peak is 5-10pm. EV-TOU-5 super off-peak is the same 13.1¢ year-round, so this works Nov-Feb.
Fleet coordination strategy
For teams with multiple vehicles:
- Stagger charging: Don't charge all 8 vehicles midnight-1am (demand surge). Stagger: vehicles 1-3 charge midnight-2am, vehicles 4-6 charge 2-4am, vehicles 7-8 charge 4-6am. Keeps load smooth, avoids brownouts.
- Capacity planning: 8 vehicles × 70 kWh = 560 kWh over 6 hours = 93 kW average draw. Make sure your shop's electrical service can handle it. Most commercial services (200A+) can, but get an electrician to verify before charger install.
- Monthly billing: If you can shift all fleet charging to off-peak (midnight-6am), your SDG&E bill drops 40-50% for charging costs. Reinvest savings into route optimization or vehicle maintenance.
Winter heating load amplifies the signal
In summer, EV charging peak is driven by air conditioning demand (which is weather dependent). In winter, peak is driven by heating (which is consistent). The winter peak is more predictable, which means:
- Same peak hours every day: 5-10pm, winter or not. Not dependent on whether it was a hot day.
- Wider off-peak window: Midnight-6am super off-peak, PLUS 10am-2pm off-peak (good for daytime charging if you have solar).
- Stronger price signal: Utilities advertise winter peak pricing more aggressively because heating is critical infrastructure.
Next: energy optimization for your operation
EV charging is one of three winter load optimization plays. Battery arbitrage and solar timing are equally important. Get a full winter energy strategy: